Submitted by NGoff6 on Fri, 07/02/2010 - 07:57
Posted in
During the storm last week, a young and healthy tree fell into the neighbors yard and crushed a portion of his wooden fence. Two questions. Do I have to pay for his fence repair? Do I have to remove or pay to have the tree removed?
Read Similar Questions
- dead tree liability
- Tree limb on neighbor's roof
- Dangerous tree removal
- Responsibility for removal of fallen tree limb.
- Can I force neighbor to take down a diseased tree?
- Insurance coverage for fallen tree.
- Neighbors and trees
- Liability for Public Shade Tree
- Old and rotten tree on my property
- Trees Overhanging the Property Line
Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws
| Forum | Last post |
|---|---|
|
I have a lease until June 2012, but I am very unhappy with my living situation, I pay half of the rent. I am a....
I cannot answer this question based upon your statement. Who are they....
|
2/8/2012 11:00 by Alexm2012 |
|
Is it legal for Massachusetts employer to send a SALARIED employee home for the day, without pay, for a dress ....
Federal and Massachusetts courts have upheld employee dress codes as l....
|
2/8/2012 09:09 by Munsterwoman |
|
Hi, I'm the grandmother of 4 beautiful grandchildren. The oldest has hit a rough spot with defiance (puberty ....
I'm very sorry about your situation and the ordeal your family is goin....
|
2/7/2012 23:02 by gramy |
|
Hello. I'm in the middle of an appeal for SSDI and my attorney asked me to get a residual functional capacity....
First, I guess it's not a good sign that you do not trust your current....
|
2/7/2012 08:18 by Adam13 |
|
Hi everybody.
I am trying to make an offer on a house, which is an estate sale. As I understand, the execut....
|
2/6/2012 13:50 by ilya980 |
|
I've been helping a friend pay for a lawyer to go to probate court.
Her ex-Boyfriend, whom she is taking to c....
|
2/6/2012 12:21 by rbiddle |
|
If I witness a person getting beat up at a party and just run away without calling the cops or helping the guy....
I don't think so. In terms of civil liability (as opposed to cri....
|
2/3/2012 07:17 by Coller |
|
My father passed away in September. The probate is over and settled, no contests to the will. My mother is the....
Your dad died in September and the probate is already settled – ....
|
2/2/2012 18:50 by JGraul |
|
Hi. My cousin is charged with possession with intent to distribute drugs in a Massachusetts court. He is not a....
Unfortunately for your cousin, if an immigrant is convicted of certain....
|
2/2/2012 08:07 by Sister6 |
|
Just curious if you have any thoughts or have read any information regarding the success rate of divorce media....
Yes, I've also seen the 90% estimate on various websites, with some me....
|
1/24/2012 11:47 by RRM |
|
Several of my colleagues will dictate consultation notes in which they state they don't have the complete hist....
The question probably boils down to whether or not such practice is wi....
|
10/2/2011 18:37 by Anonymous |
Editor's Response
If the tree was healthy and you had no prior indication that it might fall, you are probably not liable for damages caused by the tree to the fence. Follow this link for more information about damage caused by trees and branches.
However, as to your second question, you need to remove the tree or pay to have it removed. It is your property and, regardless of how it got there, it is now a trespass on your neighbor's property. Good luck.
Fallen Tree las in MA
The editors response to these (three) questions appears inconsistent with one another and inconsistent with MA rulings. Under the nationally recognized MA "Tree Law" liability for consequences arising from a healthy fallen tree appear to favor neither of the interested parties and instead consider the event an "Act of God". So, unless the injured party tries to claim a trespass and barring negligence by the owner, the MA courts have generally ruled the tree owner owes no duty to the injured party. The spirit of the law is based upon the notion that if we were all so concerned our trees would damage others property or harm them we'd either never plant a tree in the first place or cut them all down.
Now while this seems a bit ridiculous - and the logical notion of liability stands on its head - it appears so, at least in MA. Other states, after many years, appear to be changing their position, recognizing that the forested, rural and bucolic world of yesteryear has been replaced by a densely populated litigious society.
And your homeowners insurance policy is not likely to rescue either party unless there is damage. Time to write to your (MA) congressman.
Liability for trees
Not sure I follow your comment, but to clarify for other readers:
There is no liability for damage caused if your tree falls and damages property or injures people, UNLESS you were negligent in ignoring an obvious problem, such as a sick or damaged tree.
If your tree, or any other piece of property you own, is trespassing on a neighbor's property, it is your obligation to remove it. If you do not, and your neighbor is forced to pay to have your tree removed, he may be able to collect the cost of that removal in an action brought in small claims court.