Skip to main content

Should I settle my personal injury case or go to trial?

My attorney brought me an offer to settle my personal injury case. My question is how do I know if I should take it. My attorney says I should, but maybe he just wants a quick buck so he can move on to other cases. So how do I know?

Editor's Response

The reason so many personal injury cases settle before trial is that both parties fear the uncertainty of what might happen if they go to trial.  You simply never know how a jury will respond to the evidence, to the parties, or to the attorneys.  Frequently, parties to a dispute will enter arbitration or mediation rather than go to trial to avoid that uncertainty and, especially when the parties choose non-binding dispute resolution, to get some idea of how a third party (the arbitrator or mediator) will respond to the parties and the evidence.  The bottom line is that going to trial is expensive, risky, and can wear on the emotions and psyches of all parties.

 

This information may come a bit late for you, but it may help others in the future.  The best way to know whether your attorney is giving you good information is to do a good job in the selection process.  If you hire an attorneys who is responsive to your questions, who you trust, and who has a ton of experience with personal injury cases, then you will trust him or her when he recommends settlement.  You will know that he has used his experience to analyze the case and make a determination about what you can realistically expect to get as compensation for your damages. Experience is king.  If your attorney has it, he can make a valid estimation of your best outcome, your opponent's best outcome, and where the middle ground is (the number that makes sense for settlement).

 

In your case, where you obviously have doubts about your attorney, you need to talk to him and ask him to explain the numbers, something he should be able to do. Be persistent, and make sure he explains his opinion in terms and language you understand.  You should also be able to take some comfort from the contingency fee system.  Let's face it, since your attorney is going to get some percentage of your settlement, like you, he has a strong incentive to get as much as he can in settlement.  Sure, you could be correct:  He might just want to grab a quick settlement.  However, if he has appraised your case and believes he could get 30% of a $100,000 jury award, would he really settle for 30% of $50,000 settlement offer?  For more information or to post a question, visit our MA Personal Injury Discussion Forum.

 

 

Good luck.

Talk to a Lawyer Today
Find a Personal Injury Attorney in your County
Most offer FREE Consultations

Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws

ForumLast post
Hi everybody. I am trying to make an offer on a house, which is an estate sale. As I understand, the execut....
2/6/2012 13:50
by ilya980
I've been helping a friend pay for a lawyer to go to probate court. Her ex-Boyfriend, whom she is taking to c....
2/6/2012 12:21
by rbiddle
Hello. I live in Massachusetts and I'll have to file bankruptcy in the next few weeks or definitely within a ....
If it were me, I would stop using the credit card(s).  Since you ....
2/6/2012 06:45
by RCD68
I dropped my car off for repairs at a MA mechanic in my town. He had to keep the car for a couple of days to ....
Sorry about the charges, but I think the mechanic is following the law....
2/4/2012 07:03
by WinnD
Hi, there. I'm hoping to find some clarity with a landlord situation I'm currently in. Apologies for the lengt....
Short answer for a long question:  You need to review Massachuset....
2/4/2012 00:02
by klp
If I witness a person getting beat up at a party and just run away without calling the cops or helping the guy....
I don't think so.  In terms of civil liability (as opposed to cri....
2/3/2012 07:17
by Coller
My father passed away in September. The probate is over and settled, no contests to the will. My mother is the....
Your dad died in September and the probate is already settled – ....
2/2/2012 18:50
by JGraul
Hi. My cousin is charged with possession with intent to distribute drugs in a Massachusetts court. He is not a....
Unfortunately for your cousin, if an immigrant is convicted of certain....
2/2/2012 08:07
by Sister6
I just got served been divorced since 1999 ex is looking for more support and college expenses, divorce decree....
Hi. Since any matters in the divorce order or agreement relating to th....
2/1/2012 19:16
by customsporty
Just curious if you have any thoughts or have read any information regarding the success rate of divorce media....
Yes, I've also seen the 90% estimate on various websites, with some me....
1/24/2012 11:47
by RRM
Several of my colleagues will dictate consultation notes in which they state they don't have the complete hist....
The question probably boils down to whether or not such practice is wi....
10/2/2011 18:37
by Anonymous