Skip to main content

Should I settle my personal injury case or go to trial?

My attorney brought me an offer to settle my personal injury case. My question is how do I know if I should take it. My attorney says I should, but maybe he just wants a quick buck so he can move on to other cases. So how do I know?

Editor's Response

The reason so many personal injury cases settle before trial is that both parties fear the uncertainty of what might happen if they go to trial.  You simply never know how a jury will respond to the evidence, to the parties, or to the attorneys.  Frequently, parties to a dispute will enter arbitration or mediation rather than go to trial to avoid that uncertainty and, especially when the parties choose non-binding dispute resolution, to get some idea of how a third party (the arbitrator or mediator) will respond to the parties and the evidence.  The bottom line is that going to trial is expensive, risky, and can wear on the emotions and psyches of all parties.

 

This information may come a bit late for you, but it may help others in the future.  The best way to know whether your attorney is giving you good information is to do a good job in the selection process.  If you hire an attorneys who is responsive to your questions, who you trust, and who has a ton of experience with personal injury cases, then you will trust him or her when he recommends settlement.  You will know that he has used his experience to analyze the case and make a determination about what you can realistically expect to get as compensation for your damages. Experience is king.  If your attorney has it, he can make a valid estimation of your best outcome, your opponent's best outcome, and where the middle ground is (the number that makes sense for settlement).

 

In your case, where you obviously have doubts about your attorney, you need to talk to him and ask him to explain the numbers, something he should be able to do. Be persistent, and make sure he explains his opinion in terms and language you understand.  You should also be able to take some comfort from the contingency fee system.  Let's face it, since your attorney is going to get some percentage of your settlement, like you, he has a strong incentive to get as much as he can in settlement.  Sure, you could be correct:  He might just want to grab a quick settlement.  However, if he has appraised your case and believes he could get 30% of a $100,000 jury award, would he really settle for 30% of $50,000 settlement offer?  For more information or to post a question, visit our MA Personal Injury Discussion Forum.

 

 

Good luck.


Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws

Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws

ForumLast post
We sold our condo in November of 2009. We had a new house lined up-offer was accepted (per our realtor) after....
Thanks again. I think we have two issues, what the would-be sellers d....
7/30/2010 08:40
by flyers559
Several years ago my mother died and left some property in a trust with my uncle as trustee. I'm not sure but....
Yes, as a beneficiary of the trust, under Massachusetts law, you are e....
7/30/2010 07:08
by Donaldson
My fiance was arrested for a dui, his 5th. His last one was in 94, I know the time between offenses doesn't m....
The penalty would depend on how the offense was charged. They could ch....
7/29/2010 10:42
by Anonymous
I'm permanently disabled and rely on my SSDI to get by. Before i was injured and had a job I got several debt....
Your level of income, or source of income, does not generally have any....
7/29/2010 05:47
by Anonymous
First, I like your site and visit often for info about MA law. Just wondering if you saw the new Massachusett....
LOL.  Yes I will.  This thread (as you mention) discusses th....
7/28/2010 06:53
by AlbertY
My uncle appointed me as his power of attorney several years ago. Then last year he signed a health care prox....
Follow these two threads for an explanation of what a power of attorne....
7/27/2010 05:46
by Snowe55
I purchased a MP3 player from a local resident through Craigslist. The device was not compatible with my compu....
I obviously do not know what the ad said or what the seller said to yo....
7/26/2010 00:26
by Anonymous
I have a 15 month lease which terminates on August 26th. The lease states that 60 day notice is required prio....
With my limited experience in Housing Court, I have to admit I'm stump....
7/24/2010 18:09
by alyssariffic
I live in MA and I'm the permanent guardian of my nephew who is six. My sister, his mother, has been involved....
If the Probate and Family Court appointed you as the permanent guardia....
7/24/2010 09:21
by Hall83
I read the other post about the medical malpractice tribunals in Massachusetts but I'm curious about how the t....
The panel is comprised of a judge, a doctor, a lawyer and preside....
3/9/2010 05:53
by Wookie