Skip to main content

Is it possible to sue for punitive damages in small claims court?

I'm taking Dell Financial to small claims for charging a late payment fee because I made my payment too early - 27 days early is apparently considered the same as late.

I have already sent a 30 day demand letter so that I can seek triple damages but would like to make every effort possible to dissuade Dell from this sort of action in the future. This is a matter of principal for me - I am sick and tired of being treated like this by big business and I'm mad as hell and I'm not gonna take it any more! I would like to make this sort of practice as unprofitable as possible for companies like Dell (and pretty much every bank in the country!)

If punitive damages are not permitted in small claims, how difficult is it for a layman to pursue this sort of case in "big boys court". Without punitive damages its a small case and I can stand to not win back my $29. I have been to small claims three times and I'm 3 for 3. I won my last case for $2,000 against Aer Lingus and their specialist aviation law attorney so I'm confident of my ability to make and argue a case. Obviously, I'm not so clear on procedural issues.

Thanks
Mitch

Editor's Response

I think the key issue is whether the statute you are seeking damages under allows punitive damages (as required in MA if you want to collect them).  93A does not (but, as you know, you can get the triple damages).


Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws

Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws

ForumLast post
We sold our condo in November of 2009. We had a new house lined up-offer was accepted (per our realtor) after....
Thanks again. I think we have two issues, what the would-be sellers d....
7/30/2010 08:40
by flyers559
Several years ago my mother died and left some property in a trust with my uncle as trustee. I'm not sure but....
Yes, as a beneficiary of the trust, under Massachusetts law, you are e....
7/30/2010 07:08
by Donaldson
My fiance was arrested for a dui, his 5th. His last one was in 94, I know the time between offenses doesn't m....
The penalty would depend on how the offense was charged. They could ch....
7/29/2010 10:42
by Anonymous
I'm permanently disabled and rely on my SSDI to get by. Before i was injured and had a job I got several debt....
Your level of income, or source of income, does not generally have any....
7/29/2010 05:47
by Anonymous
First, I like your site and visit often for info about MA law. Just wondering if you saw the new Massachusett....
LOL.  Yes I will.  This thread (as you mention) discusses th....
7/28/2010 06:53
by AlbertY
My uncle appointed me as his power of attorney several years ago. Then last year he signed a health care prox....
Follow these two threads for an explanation of what a power of attorne....
7/27/2010 05:46
by Snowe55
I purchased a MP3 player from a local resident through Craigslist. The device was not compatible with my compu....
I obviously do not know what the ad said or what the seller said to yo....
7/26/2010 00:26
by Anonymous
I have a 15 month lease which terminates on August 26th. The lease states that 60 day notice is required prio....
With my limited experience in Housing Court, I have to admit I'm stump....
7/24/2010 18:09
by alyssariffic
I live in MA and I'm the permanent guardian of my nephew who is six. My sister, his mother, has been involved....
If the Probate and Family Court appointed you as the permanent guardia....
7/24/2010 09:21
by Hall83
I read the other post about the medical malpractice tribunals in Massachusetts but I'm curious about how the t....
The panel is comprised of a judge, a doctor, a lawyer and preside....
3/9/2010 05:53
by Wookie