Skip to main content

Nstar damaged my house-now wont pay

Last winter and an NSTAR contractor damaged my house to the sum of $2,100. Now they have denied the claim stating" NSTAR is indemnified from any damages by its subcontractors"
Can I bring them to small claims court? IF so who d I name as Defendant?

Nstar

Small claims court might be the best solution for you here, but note that the jurisdictional limit for damages in that court (not counting punitive damages) is $7000.  The small claims court is going to be much easier for a non-attorney, pro se litigant to maneuver. (anything over $7000 puts you in district court with a whole different and more complex set of procedural requirements). You can also seek treble damages in accordance w/ MA's unfair and deceptive acts and practice statue 93A even if that takes the overall proposed judgment award over the initial $2000 entry limit. Note though that it is possible for the defendant to file a motion to have a small claim removed to a district court, which is a tactic larger corporations and their attorneys employ when faced w/ small claims, but you could oppose this motion should it occur.
 
In terms of whom to name as defendant, if you have the name of the subcontractor who caused the damage, they should be named as a party, as should Nstar. If you discover there are other entities involved, such as the subcontractor's insurance company, they can be named as well. (There's no limit to the number of defendants to case, assuming they're all somehow involved in the injurious action). If there is an insurance company involved, you might try to contact them AFTER you've filed the small claim. Knowing that you're serious and there's an actual small claim pending gives you a little negotiating leverage w/ them to settle w/o having to go to court (though the small claim process is not that daunting one way or another so you don't lose much by contacting them even if they don't want to settle).

Talk to a Lawyer Today
Find a Consumer Protection Attorney in your County
Most offer FREE Consultations