Skip to main content

Disputing collection by a contractor

Made a bad choice on contractor, and now I have a problem. In short, the work done on my roof is substantively different (in my opinion) than what was proposed and verbally agreed to. I have not paid any money at this point, and I do not want the contractor to do any further work on my roof. I'd like to have it settled and be done with (of course, my opinion is that I owe nothing :->).
 
I have the original proposal for work on my roof (under $500), unsigned by either party. I have the invoice that lists different work and showing the same amount on the original proposal, unsigned by either party. I have my roof, which reflects work that is substantively different (even from the work described in the invoice). And I have a home inspectors report indicating even that work has issues. The contractor has indicated we will be sent for collection. Does he really have a claim to do so? And if so, what steps I have to take to dispute it? Do I have to file a claim against him to get a judgement regarding the original invoice? I keep seeing mention of a 93A demand letter, but my conversations with the contractor have shown no indication that he is willing to negotiate. Thank you, David

Disputes with home improvement contractor

The beauty of a 93A demand letter is that is forces the business, or contractor in this case, to respond and explain why she does not believe she owes you any money or other remedy.  If the company does not respond, then they risk facing triple damages.  You can read this post for more general information about using 93A in contractor disputes.

However, before you go there, when a consumer finds himself in a dispute with a home improvement contractor, he has some options short of litigating (and/or trying to fend off debt collectors and mechanics liens).  A good bet is to look into mediation services.  Local consumer groups, such as the Better Business Bureau, and the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office have trained mediators who can help you settle the dispute with the contractor.  Often these services are free.  Try calling the MA Attorney General’s Consumer Complaint and Information Section at (617) 727-8400 to see if you qualify.  Also, if you hired a home improvement contractor who is registered with the state, you may be able to submit the dispute to a arbitrator by using the Massachusetts Arbitration Program. Again, call the number above for more information.  Good luck.

Talk to a Lawyer Today
Find a Consumer Protection Attorney in your County
Most offer FREE Consultations

Recent Posts about Massachusetts Laws

ForumLast post
I was in a car this weekend and my friend was pulled over by the police. He had like two drinks at a party an....
Under Massachusetts law, the driver of a vehicle is required to to pro....
2/22/2012 11:40
by Inga
I want more information on specific attorneys that have experience working with employees in the pharmaceutica....
2/21/2012 12:51
by Andrew
I've known my father for seven years now but I was born outside of his first marriage. He is currently marrie....
The answer to your question may depend on whether your father has a wi....
2/21/2012 06:45
by Cluck
I live in a Cambridge condo (old building, circa 1890s) and my association recently learned that the developer....
Your roofers are correct about the three layers of roofing: a definite....
2/20/2012 02:40
by Thaddeus
My Husband and I are getting a divorce. We have a 1 year old son and also my step son who is 5. His son has li....
Sorry about your situation, but unless you have formally adopted ....
2/19/2012 20:04
by abstaley
I receive SSD and my ex-wife receives half that amount for my daughter. My daughter turns 18 this July and the....
2/19/2012 19:40
by pilotgary111
My father passed away recently and he did not have a will. He has two life insurance policies that were taken ....
Sorry about your father.  Under Massachusetts law, a beneficiary ....
2/19/2012 17:26
by mjmmccoy
I was asked to watch the apartment of someone who was going away for a few days (I am 23). A grease fire accid....
2/19/2012 13:43
by jelly6466
I was in a Management Position at a Worlwide Corporation. Against my reccomendation a person was hired who app....
2/16/2012 22:02
by logico50
Hello. My sister and I are at each other's throats over the care of our elderly parents. They suffer in dif....
Yes.  Using mediation to deal with elder issues of the sort you m....
2/9/2012 11:15
by Gwyneth
Several of my colleagues will dictate consultation notes in which they state they don't have the complete hist....
The question probably boils down to whether or not such practice is wi....
10/2/2011 18:37
by Anonymous